Pretty Much Just the Agony of Defeat: Introducing My Son to the World of Sports
It’s probably cliché – but for people like me, pretty much a badge of honor – to admit to being one of those kids always picked last when picking teams to play sports at recess. And it’s also cliché, but cliché grafted from years and years of experience, that Those Picked Last in recess games hope against hope that just one of those times, that they might be picked not-quite-last. You don’t hope for much in those instances – just having your name called when there are three or four other kids left standing in line. But when you’re the shortest, slowest, least coordinated kid in your class, that never happens. The Law of Averages is always trumped by the Laws of the Playground.
And I think there’s a special sort of pain when Those Picked Last grow up to witness their sons following in their ignoble footsteps, standing against the fence, watching the jocks, and then the moderately coordinated, and then the obese, the scrawny, the inevitable kid with the thick glasses, all being deemed somehow more worthy by playground captains (pretty much always jocks) than Those Picked Last. It’s the kind of pain I’m beginning to feel right now – and no matter how successful your child is other arenas, you wish that somehow, you could do something about those pesky genetics that have doomed your son to your fate a generation ago. It has that weird Old Testament miscarried justice about it – the sins of the father being passed down to the son for no good reason at all really.
My failure in sports is – and forgive me if I’m overstating, but I don’t think I am – epic. My first organized sport was T-ball; my first time up to bat, I hit the ball off the tee and ran excitedly, the wrong way, toward third base. Thirty years later, my mom still relishes telling the story, undoubtedly because it combines physical humor, which she loves, and a droll story about my failure, which she probably relishes a little more than she should.
I played baseball in fifth grade – it was my one foray into real baseball, once the memories of T-Ball had been sufficiently repressed. Because we were sponsored by the local Burger King, we were called the Whoppers, and our uniforms were an aggressive, stick-it-to-Ronald McDonald shade of yellow. This is one of the most vivid details of the season for me.
I had 19 plate appearances and didn’t get a single hit all season. Of course, because my small stature made my strike zone impossible for a fifth-grade pitcher to target, I walked 15 times – including three hit-by-pitches (twice in the head, once in the shoulder) – giving me an incredible .789 on-base percentage.
But this was 1980, before anyone actually knew what an on-based percentage was, a simpler time in which success was measured strictly by putting bat on ball. Not an easy thing to do when you’re afraid of the ball.
What this meant for my baseball career in 5th grade was, based on my batting average (and my woeful fielding), I was the least of the Whoppers.
I played two years of soccer in which I practiced in the rain and spent hours in the unholy outdoors – time that might have better been spent on reading and Top 40-radio listening – only to get stuck playing defense (read: in the back, where I’d be least likely to touch the ball) in game after game. Highlights of my soccer career were few: I once scored a goal making a penalty kick in a blowout against a goalie who might have been a worse athlete than I was, I once got to play a game on Astroturf, and I once got to call a time-out and stop play when a bee stung me. (I did not see action the rest of that afternoon, to the relief of my soccer coaches.)
My wife is cut from similar cloth. We’re the type of people who feared the Presidential Physical Fitness Test in elementary school, and still sort of fear it today. She still doesn’t know how to ride a bike. When I’ve attempted forays into organized sports over the last few years, I usually end up demoralized a few games into whatever season it might be, confirming that I am still not possessing enough natural athletic ability to be insisting on competing against people half my age. And this includes really insane endeavors, like lacrosse.
So, when my son’s school called, asking for three and four-year-olds to help round out the CYO Toddler Basketball roster, you figured we might be the least likely candidates to offer our son up. “It’s sports,” we might have said. “That always tends to end pretty badly.”
They sold it to us by telling us that the goals were shorter, that all the kids at this age tend to play at about the same level, and, the selling point that hits all parents of toddlers where they live, that the kids look really cute playing out there. And indeed, we got visions of four-foot basketball hoops, short courts, and loveable tykes (but none more loveable than our own, of course) playing together for the St. Peter Prince of the Apostles Tigers under the unifying banner of the Catholic Youth Organization.
I have to tell you some things about my son Noah before we proceed. It’s clear that Noah, at age 3 1/2 (though we’ve known this about him for several years now) is on the fast track to drama club. He’s a ham. A total performer. He’s already practicing fronting a band. His favorite song is the Ramones’ “Blitzkrieg Bop,” though the first time he heard Guns ‘N Roses’ “Sweet Child O’ Mine,” he jumped up and down non-stop in the living room, yelling, “Rock and roll rocks! Rock and roll rocks!” So I’d say “Sweet Child O’ Mine” is a close second.
He was an octopus this last Halloween – that’s what he proclaimed he wanted to be, and with $50, trips to two fabric stores, and his mother and grandfather working some costuming magic, we were able to give him a fabulous costume complete with $20-a-yard pink fabric with little raised circles all across it which looked uncannily like the underside of real octopus tentacles.
He pretends to be, on any given day, a T-Rex (he even holds his arms in front of him in dead-on mockery of a T-Rex’s puny arms), a dog (he barks, crawls on the floor, and, to our horror, takes his food and places it on the floor so he can eat there), or a robot (he talks in a mechanical voice and calls us “Mommy Robot” and “Daddy Robot.”) He also loves Christmas for decorations and the Sunday paper for its advertising circulars.
Noah is all these things, but it is also becoming evident he’s a second-generation underachiever in anything involving athletics.
Basketball is a challenge for toddlers because it involves hand-eye coordination skills that are still beyond most of them. Dribbling a basketball while running stupifies nearly all of them. The toddler basket our CYO league usese for the three and four-year-olds is actually a backboard and hoop that fits over the gym’s existing regulation 10-foot hoop, so they’re shooting at an eight-foot-hoop instead, which is still daunting for kids who are barely three feet tall. On the backboard, it actually says, “No Dunking,” though we’re clearly in no danger of that. The teams play 32-minute games, 4 quarters of 8 minutes each, and it’s not unusual to have games end by a score of 2-0. Scoring a basket is toddler basketball is tantamount to scoring a goal in soccer – there’s a lot of tension building up to the actual score, near-misses are mourned as missed opportunities, and the ball actually finding net dramatically changes the complexion of a game.
Essentially, unless you’re a parent of one of the kids playing, toddler basketball is not quite a riveting brand of the sport.
Noah’s first three games went like this:
Game 1. This game became a “practice game” when the opposing team from Our Lady of Grace didn’t dress enough players to qualify for the game. The coaches somehow neglected to get Noah into the game. He ran around in the pre-game, and didn’t even take a shot during shooting drills because running around was a lot more fun. He and one of his classmates from his K-3 class spent much of the second half sitting on the bench pretending to be fish. We thought he might get into the game late, as one of the girls assigned to play the second half had drifted completely off the court to play with friends, but the false alarm just allowed him the chance to get accustomed to his regulation kneepads. In many cases with the players, the kneepads’ primary function are not to protect the players’ knees, but to keep their CYO-issue Youth XS shorts from falling to their ankles.
Game 2: This was at Mount Sacred Heart, a Catholic school across the street from a seminary and down the street from the Madonna Apartments, which are not as glamorous as they might sound. This game was a disaster before it started – we had to rouse Noah from a nap, and by the time he got to the game, he was still cranky and having none of this whole basketball thing. Because of the Game 1 failure of justice, the coaches decided Noah would start to make it up to him, but he was pointedly not in the mood. For the entire eight-minute quarter, he stood in one spot on the court and cried, pitifully. When the crowd noise got to be too much, he put his hands over his ears and cried more insistently.
This took us back to a particularly bad parenting moment. We took Noah to a San Antonio Spurs game for which we’d won free tickets, when he was barely a year old, and learned that taking extremely small children to an event in which 20,000 people will stand up and yell unexpectedly and inexplicably is a Bad Move.
Though this was two years later and there were about 19,960 less people than at that fateful Spurs game, Noah was still having none of the screaming. I tried to bribe him after his initial exit at the end of the first quater, knowing he was due to get back into the game, with the promise of McDonald’s, if he would just run and somehow become engaged with the action. He did not engage, but demanded McDonald’s after the game was over, and had a Level Four tantrum on the court as I struggled to wrest his oversized loaner kneepads from his flailing legs.
Game 3: As Noah didn’t cry on the court during this one, it was a marked improvement over Game 2. I was still the most involved parent there, actually clambering onto the court repeatedly to pull up Noah’s shorts and kneepads, encouraging him to run and get the ball. He did, at one point in the game, demonstrate an awareness that he was actually playing basketball. A girl from the other team had the ball, and Noah ran over to try to get the ball, right at the moment she was attempting to get rid of it. He ended up changing the trajectory of the pass, it went off another player on the other team, and our team ended up with the ball. I don’t think you’d technically call that a steal, as he didn’t end up with possession of the ball, but it was a moment in which Noah actually looked like he knew what he was doing. I still have a personal highlight reel in my head, comprised of sports moments through the years in which I look like I know what I’m doing. They usually don’t follow each other very closely, and they’re usually the result of dumb luck and the Law of Averages that dictates if you’re out on the court or the field long enough, you manage to do something right. Still, though, I cheered it like any proud parent would. Maybe more so, since I know how hard those moments are to come by.
By the way, we lost this game – the other team scored the game’s only basket at the start of the second half, and as it was my turn to work concessions, I spent much of the fourth quarter pouring nacho cheese over inferior tortilla chips and pulling suspiciously neon shades of Gatorade out of coolers.
Those three games are turning out to be a telling microcosm of the season. Noah missed Game 4 because we were out Christmas shopping and he was more transfixed with the wrapping paper at Target than the prospect of actually having to go play a game. Game 5 was an intrasquad scrimmage because the team from Blessed Sacrament failed to show up. Noah was engaged in the first half, in large part because his grandparents showed up for the game, but in the second half, abandoned all pretense of basketball as he suddenly decided he was a dinosaur, and chased a classmate around the court for the remainder of the game, turning the 5-on-5 into a 4-on-4 with wacky dinosaur antics as a sideshow.
So, why do we insist? It’s clear that Noah lacks the acumen, the attention, the height, and the coordination to excel on the basketball court. The four-year-olds, who aren’t in the same classroom with Noah and therefore don’t have a daily front row to the Noah Show, are perplexed. One of the more serious athletes on the team has dubbed Noah as “silly,” and when he’s decided to be a robot or a maniac chewing on his sleeve during practice, it’s hard to disagree.
Part of the reason we all insist on sports, I think, has something to do with the desire to teach teamwork. It’s drilled into us throughout our school years. We’re supposed to learn cooperation and sharing, and at some point in the K-12 trajectory, this manifests as an ill-fated group project in which two overachievers do all the work and the rest of the group goofs off. Team sports are supposed to teach those all-important skills of sharing and depending on others, while also emphasizing individual athletic prowess. Team sports, while bringing a group of kids together under the same banner with ostensibly the same goals, divides the world into stars and role players.
To our coaches’ credit, they don’t take themselves as seriously as coaches might. The head coach has a whistle, but he rarely uses it. The coaching style, necessitated by the attention span of their young charges, is basically what you would call “shepherding.” I think, however, as the kids get older, the coaches get more serious – at one of the games featuring five and six-year-olds, I witnessed four coaches from the St. Mark’s team adorned in matching St. Mark’s CYO shirts and caps.
At the toddler level, winning and losing isn’t so important, because most of the kids aren’t quite yet tapped into the concept of winning and losing. But when we’re in the stands imploring Noah to pass the ball to one of the few kids with the upper-body strength needed to hoist the ball in the general vicinity of the 8-foot rim, we’re already internalizing the difference between stars and role players, and are making an effort to ascribe them to the players.
Part of it, also, is an attempt to teach our toddlers the importance of sports. In our culture, sports is a language. Learning the language is a necessary male rite of passage, and being able to hold your own in a discussion about sports is as important to American men as proper table manners and mastering a firm handshake.
Of course, it’s possible to get along with it – there are certain subsets for whom a lack of sports knowledge is a credibility-maker – but sports has two distinct advantages for bringing us together: it ties into civic pride (the team represents our city) and provides a convenient common ground for small-talky conversations (“Hey, co-worker, did you see the game last night?”). And really, there’s something non-verbally electrifying about seeing a dunk or a touchdown catch or a home run that makes sports so appealing. There’s probably some deep-seated sociological explanation that goes back to Og throwing the spear that felled a saber-tooth tiger 20,000 years ago, and involuntary stirrings in reaction to such feats hard-wired into our DNA, and our bizarre efforts to replicate that brand of human triumph in our ever-antiseptic modern society today.
If we didn’t respond to sports on such a primal level, I don’t think there’d be the culture that has come up around sports, in which we wax poetic about exploits on the field and fret about the status of their multi-million dollar contracts and keeping certain favorite athletes in our home cities. We make them heroes – despite athletes asking us not to do that –because it’s so hard to find them in other aspects of our lives. Firemen saving babies from burning buildings – well, that’s an abstract heroism that doesn’t reach us on a personal level as much as we’d like it to. Political leaders are rarely heroic, due to rampant partisanship and an increased cynicism about politicians that started with Watergate and has just gotten more fierce and jaundiced since. For instance, I have a co-worker who maintains, in all seriousness, that Clinton spoiled the integrity of the Presidency when he played the saxophone on national TV. So, no, we’re probably not going to be treating our leaders as heroes anytime soon, no matter how many votes they get.
That’s not to say we entirely lionize athletes. Thanks to the rise of ESPN and Jim Rome, we’ve entered a new era of sports-watching which is refreshingly post-modern. The new era of sports commentary reveres athletes at it always has, but also isn’t afraid to poke fun at them in a more sophisticated manner than sports blooper video reels ever could. It’s essentially celebrity gossip, with all the snarkiness and thinly-veiled jealousy, but at the same time, it’s a celebration of ourselves as fans that are perhaps more discerning than the fans of a generation ago. It’s not enough to root for favorite teams anymore – we’re in an age where information permeates our lives, opinions pour out of us, and we’re expanding the capacity of sports to entertain. Though we react in very fundamentally unsophisticated ways to a dunk or a home run, we are much more sophisticated in what we say during time-outs and in between pitches.
Even at the low-stakes levels of toddler basketball, we’re a group of fans who see sports as not just a quest to put a ball through a hoop, but as a conglomeration of personalities that are expressed on the stage of a Catholic school’s gym. And while Noah’s not the most gifted athlete on the court – clearly, he’s far from it – he’s one of the best-defined personalities out there. His unpredictability – namely, his ability to morph from imperfect athlete to prehistoric creature in a flash – has made him a crowd favorite among the St. Peter’s parents set.
So while Noah may never score the winning basket – or any basket, for that matter – we feel like we’re doing a good thing by cheering him on.
We know and accept his potential limitations already – we’re not going to impose Todd Marinovich-levels of expectation on him, and not only because Marinovich totally cracked under the pressure of being groomed to NFL superstardom from the cradle, making it to the NFL but burning out and picking up a drug habit along the way and generally becoming a Cautionary Tale centering around not only the dangers of a parent’s inflated expectations but never being allowed to eat a Big Mac.
But that’s not to say that he’s not going to blossom into an athlete on some level later. A friend of mine who works in PR points out that she did have an inclination toward sports in her youth. You’d never guess it today -- she does a spot-on impersonation of Velma from Scooby Doo and collects snowglobes – but she played basketball, volleyball, ran track during her school years, and also branched out into cheerleading.
She wrote to me in an e-mail, “I think it's good to let children be whatever they envision themselves to be at whatever age they are without the threat of siblings or parents saying, ‘You're bookish’ or ‘You're pretty’ or whatever. I gave up on being athletic when it was drilled into me that short people shouldn't be dancers and my sisters were prettier than me. It didn't take a whole lot to sink back into a comfort zone of ‘I'm not athletic,’ even though at one point, I did get good at it.”
A great point here, to be sure: You don’t want to set up your child for the pitfalls of the self-fulfilling prophecy. For all the signs that Noah is something different – just last night, he combed tangles into his mother’s hair and called himself Fancy the Hairdresser – we feel duty-bound as parents to throw normalizing experiences in his path and see what he’ll do with them. And as ludicrous as basketball for Noah might seem now, he’s undoubtedly richer for the experience. It sure beats plopping him down in front of the TV and letting him absorb commercials telling him what to buy. (Which is why we favor Noggin over the insidious Disney Channel, but that’s a whole other essay.)
And I have to admit, although I see definite limitations in his athletic development, I’m proud that even a setting like a basketball court just appears to him, most of the time, to be a big stage. In an atmosphere resplendent with tennis shoes and whistles, we might be getting a preview of his drama club days, or his onstage rock persona, or an amusing story to tell when he’s a star point guard on his high school basketball team.
A toddler is not quite the tabula rasa that a newborn is. You already begin to see definite signs of a personality, and despite the developmental eddies of Oedipal Complex and Mine and Let’s Test Boundaries, it’s the natural inclination of the parent of a toddler to want to project to adulthood. Maybe, in some way, toddler basketball has become a piece of that in our lives, which remaining, paradoxically, at the same time, a reminder that a toddler still has a lot of discovery and a lot of growing up to do before becoming an adult. And we, as parents, have to both be tuned in to what will serve our children best and what unforeseen potential there might be in any given arena our children wander into.
And I think there’s a special sort of pain when Those Picked Last grow up to witness their sons following in their ignoble footsteps, standing against the fence, watching the jocks, and then the moderately coordinated, and then the obese, the scrawny, the inevitable kid with the thick glasses, all being deemed somehow more worthy by playground captains (pretty much always jocks) than Those Picked Last. It’s the kind of pain I’m beginning to feel right now – and no matter how successful your child is other arenas, you wish that somehow, you could do something about those pesky genetics that have doomed your son to your fate a generation ago. It has that weird Old Testament miscarried justice about it – the sins of the father being passed down to the son for no good reason at all really.
My failure in sports is – and forgive me if I’m overstating, but I don’t think I am – epic. My first organized sport was T-ball; my first time up to bat, I hit the ball off the tee and ran excitedly, the wrong way, toward third base. Thirty years later, my mom still relishes telling the story, undoubtedly because it combines physical humor, which she loves, and a droll story about my failure, which she probably relishes a little more than she should.
I played baseball in fifth grade – it was my one foray into real baseball, once the memories of T-Ball had been sufficiently repressed. Because we were sponsored by the local Burger King, we were called the Whoppers, and our uniforms were an aggressive, stick-it-to-Ronald McDonald shade of yellow. This is one of the most vivid details of the season for me.
I had 19 plate appearances and didn’t get a single hit all season. Of course, because my small stature made my strike zone impossible for a fifth-grade pitcher to target, I walked 15 times – including three hit-by-pitches (twice in the head, once in the shoulder) – giving me an incredible .789 on-base percentage.
But this was 1980, before anyone actually knew what an on-based percentage was, a simpler time in which success was measured strictly by putting bat on ball. Not an easy thing to do when you’re afraid of the ball.
What this meant for my baseball career in 5th grade was, based on my batting average (and my woeful fielding), I was the least of the Whoppers.
I played two years of soccer in which I practiced in the rain and spent hours in the unholy outdoors – time that might have better been spent on reading and Top 40-radio listening – only to get stuck playing defense (read: in the back, where I’d be least likely to touch the ball) in game after game. Highlights of my soccer career were few: I once scored a goal making a penalty kick in a blowout against a goalie who might have been a worse athlete than I was, I once got to play a game on Astroturf, and I once got to call a time-out and stop play when a bee stung me. (I did not see action the rest of that afternoon, to the relief of my soccer coaches.)
My wife is cut from similar cloth. We’re the type of people who feared the Presidential Physical Fitness Test in elementary school, and still sort of fear it today. She still doesn’t know how to ride a bike. When I’ve attempted forays into organized sports over the last few years, I usually end up demoralized a few games into whatever season it might be, confirming that I am still not possessing enough natural athletic ability to be insisting on competing against people half my age. And this includes really insane endeavors, like lacrosse.
So, when my son’s school called, asking for three and four-year-olds to help round out the CYO Toddler Basketball roster, you figured we might be the least likely candidates to offer our son up. “It’s sports,” we might have said. “That always tends to end pretty badly.”
They sold it to us by telling us that the goals were shorter, that all the kids at this age tend to play at about the same level, and, the selling point that hits all parents of toddlers where they live, that the kids look really cute playing out there. And indeed, we got visions of four-foot basketball hoops, short courts, and loveable tykes (but none more loveable than our own, of course) playing together for the St. Peter Prince of the Apostles Tigers under the unifying banner of the Catholic Youth Organization.
I have to tell you some things about my son Noah before we proceed. It’s clear that Noah, at age 3 1/2 (though we’ve known this about him for several years now) is on the fast track to drama club. He’s a ham. A total performer. He’s already practicing fronting a band. His favorite song is the Ramones’ “Blitzkrieg Bop,” though the first time he heard Guns ‘N Roses’ “Sweet Child O’ Mine,” he jumped up and down non-stop in the living room, yelling, “Rock and roll rocks! Rock and roll rocks!” So I’d say “Sweet Child O’ Mine” is a close second.
He was an octopus this last Halloween – that’s what he proclaimed he wanted to be, and with $50, trips to two fabric stores, and his mother and grandfather working some costuming magic, we were able to give him a fabulous costume complete with $20-a-yard pink fabric with little raised circles all across it which looked uncannily like the underside of real octopus tentacles.
He pretends to be, on any given day, a T-Rex (he even holds his arms in front of him in dead-on mockery of a T-Rex’s puny arms), a dog (he barks, crawls on the floor, and, to our horror, takes his food and places it on the floor so he can eat there), or a robot (he talks in a mechanical voice and calls us “Mommy Robot” and “Daddy Robot.”) He also loves Christmas for decorations and the Sunday paper for its advertising circulars.
Noah is all these things, but it is also becoming evident he’s a second-generation underachiever in anything involving athletics.
Basketball is a challenge for toddlers because it involves hand-eye coordination skills that are still beyond most of them. Dribbling a basketball while running stupifies nearly all of them. The toddler basket our CYO league usese for the three and four-year-olds is actually a backboard and hoop that fits over the gym’s existing regulation 10-foot hoop, so they’re shooting at an eight-foot-hoop instead, which is still daunting for kids who are barely three feet tall. On the backboard, it actually says, “No Dunking,” though we’re clearly in no danger of that. The teams play 32-minute games, 4 quarters of 8 minutes each, and it’s not unusual to have games end by a score of 2-0. Scoring a basket is toddler basketball is tantamount to scoring a goal in soccer – there’s a lot of tension building up to the actual score, near-misses are mourned as missed opportunities, and the ball actually finding net dramatically changes the complexion of a game.
Essentially, unless you’re a parent of one of the kids playing, toddler basketball is not quite a riveting brand of the sport.
Noah’s first three games went like this:
Game 1. This game became a “practice game” when the opposing team from Our Lady of Grace didn’t dress enough players to qualify for the game. The coaches somehow neglected to get Noah into the game. He ran around in the pre-game, and didn’t even take a shot during shooting drills because running around was a lot more fun. He and one of his classmates from his K-3 class spent much of the second half sitting on the bench pretending to be fish. We thought he might get into the game late, as one of the girls assigned to play the second half had drifted completely off the court to play with friends, but the false alarm just allowed him the chance to get accustomed to his regulation kneepads. In many cases with the players, the kneepads’ primary function are not to protect the players’ knees, but to keep their CYO-issue Youth XS shorts from falling to their ankles.
Game 2: This was at Mount Sacred Heart, a Catholic school across the street from a seminary and down the street from the Madonna Apartments, which are not as glamorous as they might sound. This game was a disaster before it started – we had to rouse Noah from a nap, and by the time he got to the game, he was still cranky and having none of this whole basketball thing. Because of the Game 1 failure of justice, the coaches decided Noah would start to make it up to him, but he was pointedly not in the mood. For the entire eight-minute quarter, he stood in one spot on the court and cried, pitifully. When the crowd noise got to be too much, he put his hands over his ears and cried more insistently.
This took us back to a particularly bad parenting moment. We took Noah to a San Antonio Spurs game for which we’d won free tickets, when he was barely a year old, and learned that taking extremely small children to an event in which 20,000 people will stand up and yell unexpectedly and inexplicably is a Bad Move.
Though this was two years later and there were about 19,960 less people than at that fateful Spurs game, Noah was still having none of the screaming. I tried to bribe him after his initial exit at the end of the first quater, knowing he was due to get back into the game, with the promise of McDonald’s, if he would just run and somehow become engaged with the action. He did not engage, but demanded McDonald’s after the game was over, and had a Level Four tantrum on the court as I struggled to wrest his oversized loaner kneepads from his flailing legs.
Game 3: As Noah didn’t cry on the court during this one, it was a marked improvement over Game 2. I was still the most involved parent there, actually clambering onto the court repeatedly to pull up Noah’s shorts and kneepads, encouraging him to run and get the ball. He did, at one point in the game, demonstrate an awareness that he was actually playing basketball. A girl from the other team had the ball, and Noah ran over to try to get the ball, right at the moment she was attempting to get rid of it. He ended up changing the trajectory of the pass, it went off another player on the other team, and our team ended up with the ball. I don’t think you’d technically call that a steal, as he didn’t end up with possession of the ball, but it was a moment in which Noah actually looked like he knew what he was doing. I still have a personal highlight reel in my head, comprised of sports moments through the years in which I look like I know what I’m doing. They usually don’t follow each other very closely, and they’re usually the result of dumb luck and the Law of Averages that dictates if you’re out on the court or the field long enough, you manage to do something right. Still, though, I cheered it like any proud parent would. Maybe more so, since I know how hard those moments are to come by.
By the way, we lost this game – the other team scored the game’s only basket at the start of the second half, and as it was my turn to work concessions, I spent much of the fourth quarter pouring nacho cheese over inferior tortilla chips and pulling suspiciously neon shades of Gatorade out of coolers.
Those three games are turning out to be a telling microcosm of the season. Noah missed Game 4 because we were out Christmas shopping and he was more transfixed with the wrapping paper at Target than the prospect of actually having to go play a game. Game 5 was an intrasquad scrimmage because the team from Blessed Sacrament failed to show up. Noah was engaged in the first half, in large part because his grandparents showed up for the game, but in the second half, abandoned all pretense of basketball as he suddenly decided he was a dinosaur, and chased a classmate around the court for the remainder of the game, turning the 5-on-5 into a 4-on-4 with wacky dinosaur antics as a sideshow.
So, why do we insist? It’s clear that Noah lacks the acumen, the attention, the height, and the coordination to excel on the basketball court. The four-year-olds, who aren’t in the same classroom with Noah and therefore don’t have a daily front row to the Noah Show, are perplexed. One of the more serious athletes on the team has dubbed Noah as “silly,” and when he’s decided to be a robot or a maniac chewing on his sleeve during practice, it’s hard to disagree.
Part of the reason we all insist on sports, I think, has something to do with the desire to teach teamwork. It’s drilled into us throughout our school years. We’re supposed to learn cooperation and sharing, and at some point in the K-12 trajectory, this manifests as an ill-fated group project in which two overachievers do all the work and the rest of the group goofs off. Team sports are supposed to teach those all-important skills of sharing and depending on others, while also emphasizing individual athletic prowess. Team sports, while bringing a group of kids together under the same banner with ostensibly the same goals, divides the world into stars and role players.
To our coaches’ credit, they don’t take themselves as seriously as coaches might. The head coach has a whistle, but he rarely uses it. The coaching style, necessitated by the attention span of their young charges, is basically what you would call “shepherding.” I think, however, as the kids get older, the coaches get more serious – at one of the games featuring five and six-year-olds, I witnessed four coaches from the St. Mark’s team adorned in matching St. Mark’s CYO shirts and caps.
At the toddler level, winning and losing isn’t so important, because most of the kids aren’t quite yet tapped into the concept of winning and losing. But when we’re in the stands imploring Noah to pass the ball to one of the few kids with the upper-body strength needed to hoist the ball in the general vicinity of the 8-foot rim, we’re already internalizing the difference between stars and role players, and are making an effort to ascribe them to the players.
Part of it, also, is an attempt to teach our toddlers the importance of sports. In our culture, sports is a language. Learning the language is a necessary male rite of passage, and being able to hold your own in a discussion about sports is as important to American men as proper table manners and mastering a firm handshake.
Of course, it’s possible to get along with it – there are certain subsets for whom a lack of sports knowledge is a credibility-maker – but sports has two distinct advantages for bringing us together: it ties into civic pride (the team represents our city) and provides a convenient common ground for small-talky conversations (“Hey, co-worker, did you see the game last night?”). And really, there’s something non-verbally electrifying about seeing a dunk or a touchdown catch or a home run that makes sports so appealing. There’s probably some deep-seated sociological explanation that goes back to Og throwing the spear that felled a saber-tooth tiger 20,000 years ago, and involuntary stirrings in reaction to such feats hard-wired into our DNA, and our bizarre efforts to replicate that brand of human triumph in our ever-antiseptic modern society today.
If we didn’t respond to sports on such a primal level, I don’t think there’d be the culture that has come up around sports, in which we wax poetic about exploits on the field and fret about the status of their multi-million dollar contracts and keeping certain favorite athletes in our home cities. We make them heroes – despite athletes asking us not to do that –because it’s so hard to find them in other aspects of our lives. Firemen saving babies from burning buildings – well, that’s an abstract heroism that doesn’t reach us on a personal level as much as we’d like it to. Political leaders are rarely heroic, due to rampant partisanship and an increased cynicism about politicians that started with Watergate and has just gotten more fierce and jaundiced since. For instance, I have a co-worker who maintains, in all seriousness, that Clinton spoiled the integrity of the Presidency when he played the saxophone on national TV. So, no, we’re probably not going to be treating our leaders as heroes anytime soon, no matter how many votes they get.
That’s not to say we entirely lionize athletes. Thanks to the rise of ESPN and Jim Rome, we’ve entered a new era of sports-watching which is refreshingly post-modern. The new era of sports commentary reveres athletes at it always has, but also isn’t afraid to poke fun at them in a more sophisticated manner than sports blooper video reels ever could. It’s essentially celebrity gossip, with all the snarkiness and thinly-veiled jealousy, but at the same time, it’s a celebration of ourselves as fans that are perhaps more discerning than the fans of a generation ago. It’s not enough to root for favorite teams anymore – we’re in an age where information permeates our lives, opinions pour out of us, and we’re expanding the capacity of sports to entertain. Though we react in very fundamentally unsophisticated ways to a dunk or a home run, we are much more sophisticated in what we say during time-outs and in between pitches.
Even at the low-stakes levels of toddler basketball, we’re a group of fans who see sports as not just a quest to put a ball through a hoop, but as a conglomeration of personalities that are expressed on the stage of a Catholic school’s gym. And while Noah’s not the most gifted athlete on the court – clearly, he’s far from it – he’s one of the best-defined personalities out there. His unpredictability – namely, his ability to morph from imperfect athlete to prehistoric creature in a flash – has made him a crowd favorite among the St. Peter’s parents set.
So while Noah may never score the winning basket – or any basket, for that matter – we feel like we’re doing a good thing by cheering him on.
We know and accept his potential limitations already – we’re not going to impose Todd Marinovich-levels of expectation on him, and not only because Marinovich totally cracked under the pressure of being groomed to NFL superstardom from the cradle, making it to the NFL but burning out and picking up a drug habit along the way and generally becoming a Cautionary Tale centering around not only the dangers of a parent’s inflated expectations but never being allowed to eat a Big Mac.
But that’s not to say that he’s not going to blossom into an athlete on some level later. A friend of mine who works in PR points out that she did have an inclination toward sports in her youth. You’d never guess it today -- she does a spot-on impersonation of Velma from Scooby Doo and collects snowglobes – but she played basketball, volleyball, ran track during her school years, and also branched out into cheerleading.
She wrote to me in an e-mail, “I think it's good to let children be whatever they envision themselves to be at whatever age they are without the threat of siblings or parents saying, ‘You're bookish’ or ‘You're pretty’ or whatever. I gave up on being athletic when it was drilled into me that short people shouldn't be dancers and my sisters were prettier than me. It didn't take a whole lot to sink back into a comfort zone of ‘I'm not athletic,’ even though at one point, I did get good at it.”
A great point here, to be sure: You don’t want to set up your child for the pitfalls of the self-fulfilling prophecy. For all the signs that Noah is something different – just last night, he combed tangles into his mother’s hair and called himself Fancy the Hairdresser – we feel duty-bound as parents to throw normalizing experiences in his path and see what he’ll do with them. And as ludicrous as basketball for Noah might seem now, he’s undoubtedly richer for the experience. It sure beats plopping him down in front of the TV and letting him absorb commercials telling him what to buy. (Which is why we favor Noggin over the insidious Disney Channel, but that’s a whole other essay.)
And I have to admit, although I see definite limitations in his athletic development, I’m proud that even a setting like a basketball court just appears to him, most of the time, to be a big stage. In an atmosphere resplendent with tennis shoes and whistles, we might be getting a preview of his drama club days, or his onstage rock persona, or an amusing story to tell when he’s a star point guard on his high school basketball team.
A toddler is not quite the tabula rasa that a newborn is. You already begin to see definite signs of a personality, and despite the developmental eddies of Oedipal Complex and Mine and Let’s Test Boundaries, it’s the natural inclination of the parent of a toddler to want to project to adulthood. Maybe, in some way, toddler basketball has become a piece of that in our lives, which remaining, paradoxically, at the same time, a reminder that a toddler still has a lot of discovery and a lot of growing up to do before becoming an adult. And we, as parents, have to both be tuned in to what will serve our children best and what unforeseen potential there might be in any given arena our children wander into.
